Reframing the south China sea dispute: civilizational mediation, historical memory and hybrid governance in east Asia

Oishi, Mikio (2026) Reframing the south China sea dispute: civilizational mediation, historical memory and hybrid governance in east Asia. i-LEdHS 2026 Conference Proceedings, 1 (1): 19. pp. 179-186. ISSN 978-629-93193-0-6
Abstract

This paper reinterprets the South China Sea (SCS) dispute through an interdisciplinary lens integrating international relations, historical sociology, and cultural-civilizational analysis. Rather than framing it as a military or legal contest, the study conceptualizes the SCS as a governance problem rooted in competing historical memories, normative orders, and political cultures in East Asia. Using the concepts of mediation regime and hybrid system, it examines governance through overlapping logics of alliance politics, regional diplomacy, and East Asian traditions of hierarchy, tribute, and negotiated coexistence—historically exemplified by the Ming Court system. The framework shows dispute management is shaped not only by power and law but also by civilizational narratives, identity, and historical grievance. China’s sovereignty claims are reframed from zerosum territorial assertions into historically grounded governance claims, enabling more flexible, culturally resonant mediation mechanisms. Sustainable conflict management requires institutional arrangements acknowledging China’s historical marginalization while protecting Southeast Asian states’ interests and agency. Extra-regional actors, especially the United States, face pressure to adapt to an East Asian diplomatic mode prioritizing indirect mediation, relational norms, and hybrid governance over exclusive alliance politics. By situating the SCS dispute at the intersection of history, culture, and international politics, this paper contributes to broader debates in the humanities and social sciences on managing conflicts in the Global South and East Asia. Ultimately, it argues that culturally informed and historically sensitive governance frameworks offer the most promising path toward durable regional stability and cooperative coexistence.

Item Details
Edit Item
Edit Item
Downloads & Files
[thumbnail of 150010.pdf]
Text
150010.pdf
Download (387kB)
Indexing & Metrics