Operational framework for an independent ICH commission in Malaysia

Mustafa, Nurulhuda Adabiah (2025) Operational framework for an independent ICH commission in Malaysia. Asid colloquium series 2025 extended abstract book. pp. 27-30. ISSN 97826299912958
Abstract

This paper addresses the fragmented legal and jurisdictional landscape governing intangible cultural heritage (ICH) in Malaysia. While the National Heritage Act 2005 (Act 645) serves as the primary federal legislation, its implementation is hindered by conflicts with state laws, constitutional divisions of power, and competing normative orders. This study proposes and operationalizes a new, independent statutory body: an Independent ICH Commission.
Employing a doctrinal legal analysis and a comparative approach with nations like Indonesia and the Philippines, the research identifies shortcomings in existing governance structures and proposes a practical solution. The main findings detail a comprehensive operational framework for the commission, including a multi-stakeholder composition with representation from federal and state authorities, indigenous communities, and academic experts. The commission's key mandates would include acting as a neutral arbiter for federal-state disputes, harmonizing heritage policies through a "Model State Heritage Law," and institutionalizing mandatory Cultural Impact Assessments (CIAs). A core principle of the framework is a shift towards genuine community empowerment by providing legal aid and support for community-led nominations. The paper concludes that establishing this commission as a statutory body with legal enforcement authority is essential to creating a robust, inclusive, and forward-looking heritage governance system in Malaysia that reflects the nation's cultural pluralism and unlocks its economic potential.

Item Details
Edit Item
Edit Item
Downloads & Files
[thumbnail of 149846.pdf]
Text
149846.pdf
Download (5MB)
Indexing & Metrics