Sahrom, Nor Ashikin (2014) A znumber extension of an integrated analytic hierarchy process – fuzzy data envelopment analysis for risk assessment / Nor Ashikin Sahrom. Masters thesis, Universiti Teknologi MARA.
Abstract
Multiple Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) problems always involve uncertainty and vague values since human judgments are highly subjective. Fuzzy concept has been applied extensively in MCDM to cater for the vagueness involved. However, the reliability of information given by fuzzy numbers is questionable. Hence, Znumber was introduced to enhance the reliability of fuzzy numbers. Usage of Znumber is very limited due to its newly introduced concept. Thus, the effect of R (reliability component) on solving MCDM problems has not been thoroughly explored and clearly explained. This is due to several available techniques on how R (reliability component) could be integrated into A (restriction component). The main objective of this study is to analyze the impact of introducing the concept of reliability of Znumber into a hybrid Analytic Hierarchy ProcessFuzzy Data Envelopment Analysis (AHPFDEA) for risk assessment purposes. The Znumber extension to MCDM problem has been implemented to rank the risk priority of bridge structures. The criteria weights for decision criteria were determined using AHP. Next, two different types of multiplication relation operations were used to integrate R into A to deal with the linguistic decision making problems. Finally, a Znumber AHPFDEA model is developed and used to rank the priority risk of the bridge structures. A numerical example has been explored to illustrate the applications of the proposed Analytic Hierarchy ProcessZNumber Data Envelopment Analysis (AHPZDEA) methodology in MCDM. Analysis on the feasibility of using AHPZDEA methodology was investigated and presented on comparisons between AHPFDEA and AHPZDEA. Both FDEA and ZDEA are found to be suitable to be used in calculating risk priority of bridge structures. However, using ZDEA ensures the uncertainty of the data used is captured in the process of ranking. On top of overall ranking in MCDM, the proposed Znumber methods could also differentiate the risk priority ranking of each criteria used. This information is crucial in studying the characteristics of each decision alternatives with respect to each criterion. In other words, the strength and weaknesses of each decision alternatives could be identified. The discussion on the impact of Znumber in MCDM in particular risk assessment contributes to broaden the scope of Znumber related to solving MCDM problem. Furthermore, limitations and strength of Znumber when applied to solving MCDM problem can be identified in particular the differences in multiplication relation operations used to integrate R into A. Thus, suitable steps to overcome limitations of Znumber in MCDM problem can be further explored.
Download
Text
TM_NOR ASHIKIN SAHROM CS 14_5.pdf Download (1MB) 
Metadata
Item Type:  Thesis (Masters)  

Creators: 


Divisions:  Faculty of Computer and Mathematical Sciences  
Item ID:  16365  
Uncontrolled Keywords:  Integrated analytic hierarchy process; Fuzzy data; Risk assessment  
URI:  http://ir.uitm.edu.my/id/eprint/16365 
Actions (login required)
View Item 